Updated September 11, 2026 · 7 min read
By Boise Bath — bathroom & shower remodeling in Boise & the Treasure Valley
The short answer
A filled 60-inch tub with a bather runs roughly 730–760 lbs in both cast iron and acrylic. Kohler publishes 310 lbs and 32.6 gallons for its cast iron Bellwether and 73 lbs and 57 gallons for its acrylic Archer — so the light tub holds 24 more gallons and lands within about 34 lbs of the heavy one.
Key takeaways
- Empty weight is the number everyone compares and the least useful one. Kohler’s cast iron Bellwether is 310 lbs; its acrylic Archer is 73 lbs — a 4.2× difference that mostly disappears once both are full.
- Water is the dominant load. At 8.34 lbs per gallon, the Archer’s 57-gallon capacity is 475 lbs of water against the Bellwether’s 32.6 gallons and 272 lbs.
- Kohler publishes a Minimum floor load on its bath spec sheets — 52 lbs/ft² for the cast iron Bellwether and 46 lbs/ft² for the acrylic Archer. A 6 lbs/ft² gap, for tubs 237 lbs apart empty.
- Both exceed the 40 psf uniform live load the IRC prescribes for a bathroom (Table R301.5), which is exactly why the manufacturer publishes the figure.
- The practical consequence is the opposite of the usual advice: if you are worried about a floor, the deep soaking tub deserves the same question as the cast iron one — and nobody asks it.
The short answer
A standard 60-inch bathtub, filled to its rated capacity with an adult in it, lands somewhere around 730 to 760 pounds. That figure is roughly the same whether the tub is cast iron or acrylic, which is not what most people expect.
It surprises people because the comparison everybody makes is the empty one. Empty, a cast iron tub is four times heavier than an acrylic one. Full, the gap nearly closes, because the acrylic tub in this comparison holds 24 more gallons of water — and water is the heaviest thing in the room.
The manufacturers publish this, and almost nobody reads it
Kohler’s specification sheets carry four fields that matter here: product weight, water capacity, water depth, and a Minimum floor load given in pounds per square foot. That last one is unusual — it is the manufacturer stating what the floor under the tub needs to be rated for — and it rarely appears in any consumer comparison.
Here are two tubs of the same nominal size from the same manufacturer, one in each material.
| Spec | Bellwether K-838 (cast iron) | Archer K-1946-LA (acrylic) |
|---|---|---|
| Product weight | 310 lbs | 73 lbs |
| Water capacity | 32.6 gal | 57 gal |
| Water depth | 9" | 15⅛" |
| Minimum floor load | 52 lbs/ft² | 46 lbs/ft² |
Both figures are taken directly from Kohler’s published specification sheets (K-838 and K-1946-LA). The acrylic tub weighs less than a quarter of the cast iron one and Kohler asks for a floor within 6 lbs/ft² of the same rating.
The arithmetic, shown
Water weighs about 8.34 pounds per US gallon. That single conversion is what makes the empty-weight comparison misleading — and it can be checked against the spec sheets themselves. USGS gives water’s density as roughly 1 gram per millilitre, and Kohler lists each capacity in litres as well: 123.4 L for the Bellwether and 215.8 L for the Archer, which is about 272 lbs and 476 lbs of water. Warm bath water is very slightly lighter than cold, by well under 1%, which changes nothing here.
Cast iron Bellwether: 310 lbs of tub + (32.6 gal × 8.34) = 272 lbs of water = 582 lbs, before anybody gets in.
Acrylic Archer: 73 lbs of tub + (57 gal × 8.34) = 475 lbs of water = 548 lbs, before anybody gets in.
Add a 180-pound bather and the two land at roughly 762 lbs and 728 lbs. The cast iron tub — the one every article warns you about — ends up about 34 pounds heavier in use, a difference of under 5%, despite outweighing the acrylic by 237 pounds on the delivery truck.
The deeper tub is the reason. The Archer has a 15⅛-inch water depth against the Bellwether’s 9 inches, which is exactly what people buy a soaking tub for. Depth is comfort, and depth is water, and water is load.
Where the usual advice goes wrong
Standard guidance is that cast iron is the tub to worry about on an upper floor and acrylic is the safe choice. On the delivery day that is true — 310 lbs against 73 is a real difference in how the tub gets up the stairs. On every day after that, these two are within 5% of each other. If a floor is a genuine question, it is a question about the filled weight, and the material alone does not answer it.
What the code says, and what that does and does not mean
The IRC prescribes minimum uniformly distributed live loads for residential floors in Table R301.5: 40 psf for rooms other than sleeping rooms, and 30 psf for sleeping rooms. A bathroom falls in the 40 psf category.
Both Kohler figures above — 52 and 46 lbs/ft² — exceed that. That is not a scandal and it is not a reason to panic: it is why the manufacturer publishes the number at all. A filled bathtub is a concentrated load over a small area, which is a different engineering question from the uniform live load a floor is designed against, and design minimums are not the point at which anything fails.
What it does mean is that a filled tub is a legitimate design-stage question rather than a delivery-day surprise, and that the question applies to more tubs than people think. The honest position for a remodeler is the narrow one: we can tell you what the manufacturer publishes and what the code prescribes. Whether a specific floor — with its span, its joist size, its spacing, its age and whatever a previous owner did to it — satisfies that is a question for a structural engineer, and it is a cheap question to ask before a tub is ordered rather than after it is installed.
The other number on the same sheet: hot water
Both Kohler specification sheets carry the same note: “The hot water supply should be 70% of the capacity of the bath or greater.” It sits a few lines below the floor load, and it is the half of a deep-tub decision that tends to surface only after the tub is in.
Applied to these two tubs, the Bellwether’s 32.6 gallons asks for roughly 23 gallons of hot water. The Archer’s 57 gallons asks for roughly 40.
Forty gallons is the nameplate size of a lot of household water heaters. Upgrading to a deeper tub can quietly turn into a water-heater conversation, and it is a much cheaper one to have at the design stage than on the first evening someone runs a bath.
When it is worth asking
- Ground floor on a concrete slab: not a question. The slab does not care.
- Second storey, tub staying exactly where the old one was, similar capacity: generally not a question either. The floor has been carrying that load already.
- Second storey and the tub is getting deeper or bigger: worth asking. Going from a 32-gallon alcove tub to a 57-gallon soaker adds roughly 200 lbs of water in the same footprint, and nothing about the room looks different afterwards.
- Freestanding tub on a small footprint: worth asking. The same load concentrated on four feet rather than spread across a full-length base is a different case.
- Older house, long joist spans, or any prior structural alteration: worth asking regardless of material.
- You are being told "cast iron is too heavy for upstairs" with no reference to capacity: that is folk wisdom, not analysis. Ask what the filled weight is.
The numbers for your own tub
Major tub manufacturers publish weight and water capacity on their specification sheets, and the arithmetic takes a minute:
Filled weight = product weight + (water capacity in gallons × 8.34) + occupant weight.
Not every manufacturer publishes a minimum floor load. If the spec sheet gives one, that is the manufacturer telling you what they expect the structure to be rated for — take it to whoever is assessing the floor rather than converting it yourself. If it does not give one, the filled weight and the tub’s footprint are what an engineer will want.
And if a supplier cannot produce a spec sheet for a tub they are selling you, that is worth noticing on its own. The figures in this article came from two PDFs that took under a minute each to find.
Ready to plan your Boise bathroom?
Licensed & insured · 3-year workmanship warranty
Frequently asked questions
- How much does a bathtub weigh full of water?
- Around 550 to 600 lbs for a standard 60-inch tub before anyone gets in, and roughly 730 to 760 lbs with an adult bathing. Using Kohler’s published specs: the cast iron Bellwether is 310 lbs empty and holds 32.6 gallons, giving 582 lbs filled; the acrylic Archer is 73 lbs empty and holds 57 gallons, giving 548 lbs. Water at 8.34 lbs per gallon does most of the work in both cases.
- Is a cast iron tub too heavy for a second floor?
- Usually not, and the framing of the question is the problem. Empty, a cast iron tub is genuinely hard to get upstairs — 310 lbs against 73 for acrylic. Filled, Kohler’s own figures put the two within about 34 lbs of each other, because the acrylic tub holds 24 more gallons. If the floor is a real concern it is a concern about filled weight and footprint, and a structural engineer answers it in one visit. The material by itself does not.
- What does “minimum floor load” on a spec sheet mean?
- It is the manufacturer stating what the floor beneath the tub should be rated to carry, in pounds per square foot. Kohler gives 52 lbs/ft² for its cast iron Bellwether and 46 lbs/ft² for its acrylic Archer. Both are above the 40 psf uniform live load the IRC prescribes for a bathroom, which is exactly why the figure is published. Hand it to whoever assesses your floor rather than interpreting it yourself — a filled tub is a concentrated load, which is a different calculation from a uniform one.
- Does a deeper soaking tub need a stronger floor?
- It needs more consideration, yes, because depth is water and water is the dominant load. Going from a 32-gallon tub to a 57-gallon one adds roughly 200 lbs in the same footprint, and the room looks identical afterwards. That is the case people most often miss, because they associate weight with the material rather than the capacity.
- How do I work out the weight for the tub I am buying?
- Product weight + (water capacity in gallons × 8.34) + occupant weight. Both figures are on the manufacturer’s spec sheet, which is a public PDF for every major brand. If the spec sheet also lists a minimum floor load, that is the number your builder or engineer actually wants.
Sources
- Kohler
- International Code Council (IRC/IBC)
- USGS Water Science School — Water Density
- NIST Special Publication 811 — Appendix B.8, Conversion Factors
- This Old House — Bathrooms
Claims and figures are drawn from the sources above and provided for general guidance; your project may vary. Photography is illustrative of design concepts. For a fixed price on your specific bathroom, request a free estimate.







